Caitlin Nolan

Allison Carlos

LaMonica Falkquay

  1999                 2000                 2001                 2002                2003

Desiree Wiley

1st Runner Up​

Charlotte Booth

Danielle Routt​

Top 10

Cassie Paradise

Amy Valenti

Cassie Paradise is a 21 year old resident of Staten Island where she graduated from the New Millennium Training Center. She is currently working as a medical assistant while studying to become a pediatric operating room nurse. She is dedicated to her platform, "Princess Amelia" - Raising Awareness for SUDC​, which was inspired by the sudden unexplained passing of her toddler cousin. She has been dancing for 18 years, and performs a jazz dance in pageant competitions.  

She previously served as Miss Southern Tier 2015, where she received the honor of People's Choice at the state pageant, and Miss Richmond County 2016. 

2004                 2005                 2006                 2007                2008

Laurie Jean Fanfarillo

Angie Miller

Elizabeth Sutton

Lorna Rose

Kerisa Bonville

2014                 2015                  2016                   2017

Jesse Ladoue

Miss International 2013

2009                 2010                  2011                   2012                2013

Camille Sims

​Top 10, Miss New York 2016

Stephanie Quimby

Top 10

Audra Paquette

Miss New Hampshire 2005

Miss Finger Lakes

Sarah Catherine Carr

Miss Finger Lakes Legacy

1967 Jeannie Lewis

1968 Diane Neal

1969 Carol Camenga

1970 Heather Solsky

1971 Geri Monahan

1972 Shawn Kisiah

1973 Barbara Holden

1974 Peggy Jo Sowers 

Missy Morrison

Top 10